Food

Appetizers

Oysters Rockefeller
$11.95

Oysters Rockefeller

Broiled with lemon butter, bacon, spinach and a dash of bernaise.
Gluten-Free

 
2

Fresh Shucked Oysters

Served with traditional condiments
Gluten-Free

1/2 Dozen $8.75Full Dozen $15.75
 
New FeatureTap into any item to check out guest reviews and ratings, or add your own!
$10.95

Clams Casino

Local Joe Island Clams with bacon, bread crumbs and a melted provolone topping.

 
$12.95

Florida Grouper Nuggets

1

Fresh gulf grouper lightly dusted. Served with creamy mustard sauce.

 
$8.95

Bahamian Conch Fritters

Loaded with Caribbean conch, peppers and onions, lightly fried.

 
$9.95

Jamaican Jerk Wings

Char grilled and served with celery and coconut dipping sauce.
Gluten-Free

 
$8.95

Smoked Mahi Fish Spread

A local favorite! Served with saltine crackers, and jalapefios.

 
Maryland Baked Crab Dip
$11.95

Maryland Baked Crab Dip

straight from the heart of the Chesapeake Bay.

 
$13.95

Chimichurri Filet Tips

Grilled filet tips with chimichuri for dipping.

 
$10.95

Coconut Almond Shrimp

Coconut almond crusted jumbo shrimp, served with citrus mustard.

 
$12.95

Blackened Tuna Sashimi

Fresh yellow fin, blackened and seared rare with wakami salad.
Gluten-Free

 
$11.95

Blue Crab Claws

Sauteed with a zesty garlic butter served with Parmesan crusted toast points.
Gluten-Free

 
$10.95

Calamari

Crisp, buttermilk breaded calamari with chili horseradish sauce.

 

Soups & Salads

Florida Seafood Chowder

Shrimp, scallops, fish and crab in a rich tomato broth.
Gluten-Free

Bowl $6.95Cup $4.50
 
Grilled Grouper Salad
$15.95

Grilled Grouper Salad

Florida grouper over mixed greens with avocado and bacon with sun dried tomato vinaigrette
Gluten-Free

 

Maryland Blue Crab Bisque

Blue crab, cream, herbs and a hint of sherry.

Bowl $7.95Cup $4.95
 
$3.95

House Salad

Mixed lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, carrot, radish, and croutons with creamy Italian Dressing.

 
$11.95

Grilled Chicken Cobb Salad

Avocado, tomato, egg, bacon, and chedder cheese blend with choice of dressing.
Gluten-Free

 
$14.95

Steak Caesar Salad

Grilled Angus Strip Steak over crisp romaine.

 

Entree

Sides - Corn on the Cob, Cheese Grits, Salt Potatoes, Asparagus or Tropical Slaw
All Entrees Served with side house salad.

Maryland Crab Cakes
$26.95

Maryland Crab Cakes

1

Jumbo lump crab cakes, broiled and served with creamy mustard sauce.

 
$16.95

Key West Shrimp and Grits

Sauteed Shrimp, tasso ham, mushrooms and garlic, with creamy cheese grits.

 
$18.95

Lobster Pasta

1

Sauteed lobster, shrimp, and mushrooms with penne pasta. Tossed with our brandy herb cream sauce.

 
$29.95

New York Strip

16 oz. Certified Angus strip steak, char-grilled to perfection, served with choice of two sides.
Gluten-Free

 
$44.95

Baytenders Surf & Turf

1

8 oz. broiled lobster tail, topped with crab imperial paired with a 8 oz. Certified Angus strip steak, served with choice of two sides.
Gluten-Free

 
$22.95

Blackened Snapper

Fresh local snapper, blackened and topped with pineapple, mango salsa, served with two sides.
Gluten-Free

 
$24.95

Florida Grouper Oscar

Local grilled catch topped with lump crab, hollandaise and asparagus and choice of two sides.
Gluten-Free

 
$21.95

Blackberry Grilled Salmon

Grilled filet, wild caught, with herbed blackberry glaze.
Gluten-Free

 
$15.95

Chicken Marsala Pasta

1

Sautéed chicken, mushrooms, asparagus, sundried tomatoes, bowtie pasta and rich marsala sauce.

 

From the Steamer

Mussels
$13.95

Mussels

1

PEI Mussels, sauteed with fresh tomatoes, basil and tossed with white wine lemon butter sauce.
Gluten-Free

 
Steamed Shrimp
$12.95

Steamed Shrimp

2

Old Bay and beer brew steamed large Key West Pinks, peel and eat.

 
$12.95

Clam Bowl

Local Joe Island Clams steamed in white wine and garlic broth.
Gluten-Free

 
Steamed Oysters

Steamed Oysters

Fresh shucked and lightly steamed in natural liquor.
Gluten-Free

1/2 Dozen $9.75Full Dozen $14.75
 
$26.95

Florida/Caribbean Lobster

1

Steamed warm water lobster tail, served with drawn butter and choice of one entree side.
Gluten-Free

 
Alaskan Snow Crab
$29.95

Alaskan Snow Crab

Two large clusters, served with drawn butter and choice of one entree side
Gluten-Free

Add a cluster +$13.75
 
$38.95

King Crab

1 lb. Jumbo king crab leg, steamed and served with drawn butter and choice of one entree side.
Gluten-Free

 
$27.95

Baytender's Steam Pot

Clams, mussels, shrimp, snow crab, com, sausage and potatoes steamed in Old Bay and beer.

 

Sandwiches & Baskets

Sandwiches served with your choice of one side: seasoned fries, fresh fruit or tropical slaw.
Add an additonal sandwich side for $1.95

Grouper
$15.95

Grouper

1

Fresh gulf grouper prepared blackened, grilled or fried.

 
$13.95

Crab Cake

Maryland jumbo lump crab cake, broiled.

 
$13.95

Blackened Tuna

Fresh yellowfin, blackened and seared rare.

 
$11.95

Chicken Sandwich

Walkers Wood chicken, topped with Applewood smoked bacon, BBQ Sauce and Provolone.

 
$11.95

Baytender's Bacon Cheeseburger

Half pound, hand crafted char grilled seasoned burger.

 
Mahi Tacos
$12.95

Mahi Tacos

Fresh blackened Mahi, pico, shredded cheese, and tropical slaw on grilled tortillas.

 
$13.95

Lobster & Shrimp Quesadilla

Lobster and shrimp with a blend of cheeses on crisp tortillas with fries and Slaw.

 
$12.95

Fried Oyster Basket

Fresh shucked oysters, lightly dusted, served with fries and slaw.

 
$12.95

Fried Shrimp Basket

Key West Pink Shrimp, hand breaded, lightly fried, served with fries and slaw.

 
$11.95

Fried Clam Basket

Fresh shucked jumbo clam strips, lightly breaded, served with fries and slaw.

 

Captain's Crew

Served with choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh fruit

$6.25

Captain Crunch Chicken Tenders

 
$5.25

Fried Shrimp

 
$4.25

Corn Dog

 
$6.25

Grouper Nuggets

 
$4.25

Cheese Quesadilla

 
$4.25

Mac & Cheese